A quiet evening in Lake George turned tragic after 9-year-old Melina Frattolin was reported missing by her father, Luciano Frattolin, on July 19, 2025. He told 911 she may have been abducted near I-87’s Exit 22, prompting an extensive search by multiple law enforcement agencies.

However, authorities soon found “inconsistencies” in Luciano’s story, stating, “there was no indication that an abduction took place.” Despite this, search teams, including K9 units and aviation support, continued combing the area.

Melina’s body was found days later during a grid search in Ticonderoga by a New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Officer. “The PBA of New York State is extremely saddened,” said President James McCartney, offering condolences and recognizing the emotional toll on officers.

The discovery sparked strong public reactions online, with many questioning the father’s account. “The father’s story is not adding up,” one comment read. Others expressed sorrow and called for justice: “Rest in peace sweet angel.”

Luciano, known as the founder of Gambella Coffee and a devoted father, has not been charged, but his actions remain under investigation. The New York State Police are now handling the case, with a press briefing expected July 21.