In a recently resurfaced 2004 interview, Oprah Winfrey faces renewed criticism for questioning Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen about eating disorders when they were just 17. Oprah asked Mary-Kate about her size, which drew backlash due to its insensitivity, especially considering Mary-Kate’s struggle with an eating disorder at the time. Ashley defended her sister, highlighting media scrutiny on their bodies. Critics find Oprah’s probing inappropriate, given the twins’ vulnerability.

The incident sheds light on the broader issue of media treatment of young celebrities. Viewers express shock and criticize Oprah’s approach, questioning its appropriateness. Mary-Kate’s subsequent entry into rehab for anorexia underscores the potential impact of such interviews on individuals’ well-being. The resurfaced interview adds to the ongoing cultural reckoning around media treatment of vulnerable figures. Oprah has yet to respond to the renewed scrutiny surrounding the unearthed interview.