In 1894, the San Francisco Mint produced only 24 special dimes, making them among the rarest coins in American history. Today, just nine examples are confirmed to survive, while the whereabouts of two others remain unknown. These missing coins could still be hiding in old collections or among ordinary pocket change.
One of the most famous stories surrounding the coins involves the mint superintendent’s young daughter. According to legend, she spent one of the rare dimes on ice cream, turning a simple childhood purchase into a famous story among coin collectors. The surviving examples are now divided between museums and private collections, making them extremely difficult to find.
A verified 1894-S dime has sold at auction for nearly $2 million, showing just how valuable these tiny coins can be. Collectors search for two important details: the date “1894” and the “S” mint mark, which identifies the San Francisco Mint.
However, not every coin that looks like an original is genuine. Counterfeit examples exist, so anyone who believes they have discovered one should have it professionally authenticated before attempting to sell it or keep it as a family treasure. With two coins still missing, the possibility of finding one in an old collection continues to fascinate collectors.